By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept

Your #1 guide to start a business and grow it the right way…

BuckheadFunds

  • Home
  • Startups
  • Start A Business
    • Business Plans
    • Branding
    • Business Ideas
    • Business Models
    • Fundraising
  • Growing a Business
  • Funding
  • More
    • Tax Preparation
    • Leadership
    • Marketing
Subscribe
Aa
BuckheadFundsBuckheadFunds
  • Startups
  • Start A Business
  • Growing a Business
  • Funding
  • Leadership
  • Marketing
  • Tax Preparation
Search
  • Home
  • Startups
  • Start A Business
    • Business Plans
    • Branding
    • Business Ideas
    • Business Models
    • Fundraising
  • Growing a Business
  • Funding
  • More
    • Tax Preparation
    • Leadership
    • Marketing
Made by ThemeRuby using the Foxiz theme Powered by WordPress
BuckheadFunds > Startups > A Judge Says Meta’s AI Copyright Case Is About ‘the Next Taylor Swift’

A Judge Says Meta’s AI Copyright Case Is About ‘the Next Taylor Swift’

News Room By News Room May 4, 2025 4 Min Read
Share

Meta’s copyright battle with a group of authors, including Sarah Silverman and Ta-Nehisi Coates, will turn on the question of whether the company’s AI tools produce works that can cannibalize the authors’ book sales.

US District Court Judge Vince Chhabria spent several hours grilling lawyers from both sides after they each filed motions for partial summary judgment, meaning they want Chhabria to rule on specific issues of the case rather than leaving each one to be decided at trial. The authors allege that Meta illegally used their work to build its generative AI tools, emphasizing that the company pirated their books through “shadow libraries” like LibGen. The social media giant is not denying that it used the work or that it downloaded books from shadow libraries en masse, but insists that its behavior is shielded by the “fair use” doctrine, an exception in US copyright law that allows for permissionless use of copyrighted work in certain cases, including parody, teaching, and news reporting.

If Chhabria grants either motion, he’ll issue a ruling before the case goes to trial—and likely set an important precedent shaping how courts deal with generative AI copyright cases moving forward. Kadrey v. Meta is one of the dozens of lawsuits filed against AI companies that are winding through the US legal system.

While the authors were heavily focused on the piracy element of the case, Chhabria spoke emphatically about his belief that the big question is whether Meta’s AI tools will hurt book sales and otherwise cause the authors to lose money. “If you are dramatically changing, you might even say obliterating, the market for that person’s work, and you’re saying that you don’t even have to pay a license to that person to use their work to create the product that’s destroying the market for their work—I just don’t understand how that can be fair use,” he told Meta lawyer Kannon Shanmugam. (Shanmugam responded that the suggested effect was “just speculation.”)

Chhabria and Shanmugam went on to debate whether Taylor Swift would be harmed if her music was fed into an AI tool that then created billions of robotic knockoffs. Chhabria questioned how this would impact less-established songwriters. “What about the next Taylor Swift?” he asked, arguing that a “relatively unknown artist” whose work was ingested by Meta would likely have their career hampered if the model produced “a billion pop songs” in their style.

At times, it sounded like the case was the authors’ to lose, with Chhabria noting that Meta was “destined to fail” if the plaintiffs could prove that Meta’s tools created similar works that cratered how much money they could make from their work. But Chhabria also stressed that he was unconvinced the authors would be able to show the necessary evidence. When he turned to the authors’ legal team, led by high-profile attorney David Boies, Chhabria repeatedly asked whether the plaintiffs could actually substantiate accusations that Meta’s AI tools were likely to hurt their commercial prospects. “It seems like you’re asking me to speculate that the market for Sarah Silverman’s memoir will be affected,” he told Boies. “It’s not obvious to me that is the case.”

Read the full article here

News Room May 4, 2025 May 4, 2025
Share This Article
Facebook Twitter Copy Link Print
Previous Article Why the National Thoroughbred League Is a Sports Investment Unicorn in the Making
Next Article Scale Your Small Business Without Draining Your Resources
Leave a comment Leave a comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Wake up with our popular morning roundup of the day's top startup and business stories

Stay Updated

Get the latest headlines, discounts for the military community, and guides to maximizing your benefits
Subscribe

Top Picks

Franchise Success Starts at The Local Level — Here’s Why
July 14, 2025
Why Waiting for Monthly Financial Reports Is Creating Blind Spots and Slowing Your Growth
July 14, 2025
Tornado Cash Made Crypto Anonymous. Now One of Its Creators Faces Trial
July 14, 2025
I Learned These 5 Lessons the Hard Way So You Don’t Have To
July 14, 2025
Podcasts created a new media category. Where do they go from here?
July 14, 2025

You Might Also Like

Tornado Cash Made Crypto Anonymous. Now One of Its Creators Faces Trial

Startups

Linda Yaccarino Tried to Tame X. Now She’s Out as CEO

Startups

The Teens Are Taking Waymos Now

Startups

Trump’s Defiance of TikTok Ban Prompted Immunity Promises to 10 Tech Companies

Startups

© 2024 BuckheadFunds. All Rights Reserved.

Helpful Links

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of use
  • Press Release
  • Advertise
  • Contact

Resources

  • Start A Business
  • Funding
  • Growing a Business
  • Leadership
  • Marketing

Popuplar

How The NBPA and a Top African University Are Building Player Legacies Off the Court
Linda Yaccarino Tried to Tame X. Now She’s Out as CEO
‘Obvious’ Side Hustle: From $300k Monthly to $20M+ in 2025

We provide daily business and startup news, benefits information, and how to grow your small business, follow us now to get the news that matters to you.

Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?